Helping needy Malagasy kids to become 

Jesus’ kids!

October 2009                 Volume 12, Number 10

"A generous man will himself be blessed, for he shares his food with the poor."         Proverbs 22:9


 

A Myriad of Questions

 

Andry's Dialysis Expenses for 2009

February (One Week)

$ 878.78

March

2,734.92

April

2,805.55

May

2,523.17

June

2,408.76

July

2,416.94

August

2,478.83

September

2,094.74

TOTALS

18,341.69

 

                 Betikara has encountered a mass of information concerning the care that is needed for Andry and his ongoing dialysis treatments. We are finding that the more we learn, the more questions that there are to be answered. We are also finding that our initial ideas concerning the quality of care that Andry will be able to receive in Madagascar are correct. Madagascar is not up to the task.

                 Madagascar is barely able to keep up the dialysis treatments, three times a week, that are needed to maintain Andry at an acceptable level of health. Many times, we find that there is no medicine and that the necessary expendable items that are needed for each treatment are not available at the two on-site hospital pharmacies. This entails that we search around at other hospitals and pharmacies until we are able to purchase the needed items. This searching for items is nothing new. Madagascar, as it was in Kenya, has a mindset that whatever an item might be, if there is still one item on the shelf then you do not need to concern yourself with ordering more stock. The problem is everyone has the same mindset. We are finding that when one hospital or pharmacy does not have the required supplies none of the other hospitals or pharmacies have the needed supplies. We often spend hours each day searching for the required medicines and expendable items so that Andry can have his dialysis treatment.

            Our hands are tied. Often we cannot find the needed items locally. The government will not allow us to have permission to ship in medical supplies for Andry, and the government will not give us duty free status so that we can get things into the country inexpensively. We were recently able to get 6 badly needed dialysis machines shipped into the country. Originally, the government hospital had 12 machines. Now they are down to 4 working machines. With the arrival of the 6 new machines the hospital will be able to provide more reliable care for their current patients. There have been times in the past that Andry was not able to have three dialysis treatments in a week because of broken dialysis machines.

T            hings should be better for Andry and his dialysis treatments for a while. Once the 6 machines start to break down, then we will be back to square one. The technicians at the hospital cannot seem to keep the machines in good repair. Often, they complain that there are not enough parts to replace those that are broken. This is also an ongoing problem in Madagascar. One can always buy something new off the shelf, but do not expect to be able to find parts or service for what you have purchased once that item breaks down.

            The doctors told us that the best solution for Andry is for him to have a kidney transplant operation. We looked into the possibilities and soon realized that an operation will help Andry by ending the need for dialysis treatments three times a week, but what will we do for Andry after the operation? There are several items that need further consideration.

            First, one of the biggest obstacles to having a transplant operation is the needed medication to stop the body from rejecting the new kidney. This medication has to be taken for the rest of the patient’s life. The medication is expensive, about two thirds of the monthly cost of dialysis treatments, depending on the dosage of medicine that is needed.

            Second, the doctors informed us that there are no anti-rejection medications in Madagascar, and that none of the doctors are trained to administer and check on the levels of the medication in Andry’s blood once he starts to take the medication. The doctors stated that all of the patients that have gone outside of Madagascar for kidney transplant operations have never returned to Madagascar due to the lack of necessary ongoing medical care within the country. Either they are still living outside Madagascar, or they have died due to complications from their kidney transplant operations.

            If Andry does receive a “new” kidney, where will Andry live? How will Andry earn an income and be able to care for his medical needs? These are just two of the many questions that daily plague us. Andry is not educated to the level that he could live and work outside of Madagascar. In a past newsletter we wrote that Andry did not complete primary school. So, should Betikara continue to pay for Andry’s living arrangements in some other country as well as his anti-rejection medication for the rest of Andry’s life?

            By looking at the front page of this newsletter one can easily see how much Betikara has paid for Andry’s medical expenses. This chart details 8 months of expenses. However, the expenses for February only cover the last week of February. So in reality, the chart shows just over seven full months of Andry’s dialysis costs. This may seem cheaper than costs for dialysis treatments in another country. However, many of the Malagasy Christians are starting to question the large outlay of funds, for one child, that could be used to help the other 40+ children housed at Betikara.

            We are faced with many questions. Technically, according to the Betikara statute, since Andry is no longer in school Andry is supposed to leave Betikara. We all know what will happen to Andry if he leaves Betikara with his present medical needs. Andry’s family will not be able to “pick up the ball” and provide for Andry’s ongoing medical needs. We have already watched 4 different families that had kidney dialysis patients at the government hospital struggle to come up with the needed funds for dialysis treatments. One of those four families approached me about helping them out a while ago. All four of these family have lost family members due to a lack of funds to pay for the dialysis treatments. The hospitals do not charge for the use of the dialysis machines, but the families still have to purchase the needed medications and expendable items for their family members like we do for every treatment.

            The average income for a Malagasy person is about $360.00 per year. The yearly cost for kidney dialysis treatments is turning out to be around $32,000.00 per year. A quick calculation shows that the estimated amount required for yearly dialysis care is 88.9 times more than the average annual income of a Malagasy person. For this reason the Malagasy people are quick to say, “Why waste all of that money on one sick person that is going to die anyway?” With that thought in mind, should Andry also be allowed to die?

            As American missionaries to Madagascar we are finding ourselves caught between the Malagasy mindset and the American mindset. We fully understand how hard it is for these people to try and maintain a person that is on dialysis due to the exorbitant costs and the difficulty of finding the necessary medicines and expendable items. The Malagasy people struggle with daily life and finding enough medicine to help their families with the common cold and flu. How can we expect them to be able to cope with something so out of their reach as dialysis treatments, especially when most Malagasy people do not have medical insurance like Americans? We are blessed because we have a vehicle to use while searching. Malagasy people many times go by foot, bus, or taxi. So, we can easily understand the statement, “Why waste all of that money on one sick person that is going to die anyway?”

            Please give this newsletter a lot of prayerful consideration. Please pray for Andry and the Betikara Orphanage as we try to minister to Andry’s needs, and as we try to teach the Malagasy people about their need for a spiritual life since we cannot count on our physical lives. Feel free to write to us at barryjrosie@gmail.com if you have any comments, suggestions, or questions concerning Andry and his ongoing dialysis treatments.

 

 

EXPENDITURES

Food

$1,831.53

Education

572.94 

Clothing

0.00 

Misc.

2,047.03 

Health Care

 576.24

Care Giver

2,094.74 

 

 530.35

Total expenses

$5,558.09

 


If you would like to help with a monetary donation, write your check out to BETIKARA and send it to: 

  Indiana Church of Christ 
  225 East Pike Rd. 
  Indiana, PA  15701 

“He who is kind to the poor lends to the LORD, and he will reward him for what he has done.” 
                           Proverbs 19:17
 

Return to Betikara News Archives Index

Return to top